Eating Southwest Michigan

Best Afternoon Delight - Gelato at Casual Chef Café

Be sure to stop by the Casual Chef Café and The Pumpernickel Inn along Red Arrow Highway in Union Pier, Michigan. Their selection of gelatos was outstanding - we sampled the mint chocolate chop, pistachio nut, malted chocolate and toasted coconut caramel. Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner the café is a cozy, relaxed spot. Also, if you’re in need of your “Starbucks fix” the Café serves the full line of drinks. There is also a Bed and Breakfast attached that has five unique rooms that include a full breakfast.

www.pumpernickelinn.com
16090 Red Arrow Highway, Union Pier, Michigan
269-469-1200

Best Little Market with Big Ideas — Bud & Elsie’s Union Pier Market

So it’s this tiny little place, with a screen door that smacks you in the ass as you enter - at first go-around it’s a beachy, sleepy “convenience store” and then … upon closer inspection, its this tiny little place with super great food stuffs … Scharffen Berger chocolate bars, local wines from Round Barn, St. Julian and Tabor Hill, bread from Labriola, tons of organic stuff and great housemade guacamole and hummus (we also stocked up on some of their salads - try the chicken Caesar and some ginormous sandwiches for the beach). Wine tip … try the Round Barn Merlot - this a supple sipper for post-beach porch hang time.

www.scharffenberger.com
www.labriolabaking.com
www.roundbarnwinery.com

Bud and Elsie’s
9805 Townline Road, Union Pier, Michigan
269-469-5651

Pizza How It Should Be (and don’t forget to get a salad so you can get the dressing) - Mario’s Pizza

Okay, let’s set the record straight … there’s pizza, and then there’s pizza. There’s pre-formed cardboard pizza crusts with stringy, gooey mozzarella and sub-par toppings and then, hold on to your aprons, there’s Mario’s Pizza. Walking into this place I knew I was in good hands - behind the order counter there was this smoky, black, hotter than hell Blodgett deck oven that had to be more than 60 years old. Cranking out pie after pie … this oven had some history (and I’m betting they have never washed it or sprayed it down - this is the sign of a great pizza oven - all those years of baked on flavor). We were bringing pizza and pasta back to a hungry mob back at the beach house - our stomachs ached and our mouths watered - the order was impressive: Two large pies - one with everything (and by everything, they mean everything, including sliced meatballs on top) and one simple pepperoni and cheese. For pastas, we tried the shrimp scampi, linguine and red clam sauce, pasta with meat sauce and penne in alfredo with chicken and broccoli. As we waited for our order, we played cards, talked with the locals and basically drooled. The smells were incredible …with each of our pastas we were to receive a house salad. What dressing did we want?

Me: “Whattda got?”
Mario’s Pizza Goddess and Order Taker: “Caesar, Ranch, French, Italian, Bleu Cheese”
Me: “Which one is homemade?”
Her: “All of them”
Me: “All of them?”
Her: “Yah, all of them, why’s that so hard to believe?, everything here is scratch - now which one do you want?”
Me: “I want to have all of them and … I love you”
Her: “Go sit down and wait for your stuff”

This is real pizza done perfectly - you’re not going to find any goat cheese or bbq chicken pineapple pizza - this is authentic, down-n-dirty pizza. Go eat there.

Mario’s Pizza
16170 Red Arrow Highway, Union Pier, Michigan
269-469-4633

Slow Down, Feel Special, Have Some Dinner at Bentwood Tavern

Located inside the gorgeous Marina Grand Resort in New Buffalo, Bentwood Tavern describes its food as “artisan comfort food” - I’ll agree but it does have a bit of a swanky swagger to it. We started with a fig and prosciutto pizza from the wood-burning oven and the tuna and avocado tartar - both were excellently executed and tasted divinely delicious. Next, a Caesar salad and then entrees of the evening’s fish selections — sautéed skatewing with this super rich and sexy mushroom sauce and striped sea bass with a rustic kalamata and tomato relish. Both of the dishes were plate-licking good. We ended with the lemon start and coffee. The room is simple yet artful, the service attentive and friendly and the wine list eclectic and fun (we tried the Adelsheim Pinot Gris from Oregon - a great pick to pair with our fish).

www.marinagrandresort.com
www.adelsheim.com